notfiction
Loading…

Lesson plan: Is it real?

30 minutes · ages 11 and up · free

Students play a round of Real or Fiction? with real headlines from this month and headlines from satire sites. Then the class talks through the ones that fooled them, and learns three quick checks they can use on anything they see online.

You’ll need

  • A device per student or per pair (phone, tablet, laptop or Chromebook). Nothing to install.
  • A screen or board to show the class code.
  • A class, made in a few seconds at notfiction.com/class. Students type only a first name or nickname.

Learning goals

  • Students can explain why a headline that sounds unbelievable isn’t automatically fake, and why one that sounds normal isn’t automatically real.
  • Students can use three checks: when it was published, who published it, and how many independent newsrooms report it.
  • Students can tell satire (made up on purpose, as comedy) from misinformation (made up to mislead).

The lesson

  1. Warm-up (5 minutes)Ask: “Have you ever believed something online that turned out to be fake? How did you find out?” Take three or four answers. Then ask how they decide whether to believe a headline.
  2. Play (10 minutes)Put the class code on the board. Students go to notfiction.com/class, type the code and a first name, and judge 10 headlines: Real or Fiction? They can open up to three clues per headline (when, who, how many newsrooms), but each clue costs points. Reading time is unlimited: no rushing.
  3. Discuss (10 minutes)Open your teacher page. It shows which headline fooled the most students. For that one, ask: “What made it believable?” and “Which clue would have given it away?” Then do the same for a real headline many students called fake: why did a true story sound made up?
  4. The three checks (5 minutes)Write on the board: When? Old stories get reshared as new. Who? Is the publisher a newsroom, a satire site, or a page you’ve never heard of? How many? Real news gets reported by more than one independent newsroom, usually within hours. Students write one headline they saw this week and apply the three checks for homework.

Going further

  • Start a new round from your teacher page for a second try. Do scores and clue use change once students know the three checks?
  • Check a rumor together: paste something students have seen into Is it real? and look at which newsrooms report it.
  • Who breaks the news? Who broke it first shows which newsrooms report stories before others confirm them. Good for a discussion about speed and accuracy.
  • Daily habit: the public daily game has five new headlines every day.

Good to know

  • Real headlines are stories that 3 or more of the newsrooms notfiction follows reported in the last 30 days. Fiction comes from satire sites such as The Onion and The Babylon Bee. Headlines about deaths, violence and similar subjects are left out.
  • Satire sites sometimes joke about politics and public figures, from different political sides. Preview a round with “Try it as a student” before class if you want to check it suits your students.
  • Students’ nicknames and results are seen only by the teacher, and deleted with the class after 90 days. No accounts, emails or ads.
  • “Real” means newsrooms reported it, not that every detail is proven. That distinction is a good discussion in itself.

Make a class Print this lesson